Take the First Step
December 15, 2024 · Benjamin J. Treger
An Honest Overview of Employment Case Valuation
It’s the first question almost every client asks. And the honest answer is: it depends. But “it depends” doesn’t mean “we have no idea.” Employment cases in California are valued based on specific, identifiable categories of damages, and an experienced attorney can give you a realistic range early in the process.
Here is how we think about case valuation, and what factors move the number up or down.
This is the foundation of most employment claims and often the largest single component of damages. Past lost wages cover the period from the date of the adverse action (termination, demotion, etc.) to the date of trial or settlement. Future lost wages project forward based on what you would have earned had the illegal conduct not occurred. Both include not just base salary but also bonuses, commissions, stock options or equity, retirement contributions, health insurance, and any other compensation or benefits you lost.
The calculation depends on several factors: your compensation level, how long you were out of work (or how long you are likely to be out of work), whether you found comparable employment or a lesser-paying job, your age and career trajectory, and whether the employer’s action effectively ended a career path that was otherwise on an upward trajectory.
For high-earning employees or employees who are terminated late in their careers, lost wages alone can be substantial.
California allows recovery for the psychological and emotional harm caused by illegal employment actions. This is not theoretical; it is real, recognized, and taken seriously by juries. Wrongful termination causes anxiety about financial security. Discrimination attacks a person’s dignity and sense of self-worth. Harassment creates lasting psychological effects that can persist long after the employment ends. Retaliation punishes employees for doing the right thing and creates a sense of helplessness and injustice.
Emotional distress damages are harder to quantify than lost wages because they don’t come with a pay stub. They are supported by the employee’s testimony about how the experience affected them: changes in sleep, appetite, relationships, ability to trust, self-confidence, and daily functioning. Medical records from a therapist or psychiatrist, if the employee sought treatment, provide additional support. But treatment is not required; an employee can recover emotional distress damages based solely on their own testimony about the impact.
In cases involving particularly egregious conduct (severe harassment, termination of a long-tenured employee based on disability, retaliation against a whistleblower), emotional distress damages can be the largest component of the recovery.
In cases involving malice, oppression, or fraud, California courts can award punitive damages. These are designed not to compensate the employee but to punish the employer and deter future misconduct. Punitive damages are not available in every case, but they are available in many discrimination, harassment, and retaliation cases, particularly where the employer’s conduct was intentional, where a supervisor acted with knowledge and approval of management, or where the company ratified the wrongful conduct after the fact.
The amount of punitive damages is based on the reprehensibility of the conduct and the employer’s financial condition. A Fortune 500 company faces a larger punitive award than a small business for the same conduct because the purpose is deterrence, and it takes a larger number to deter a larger company. Punitive damages are sometimes a multiple of compensatory damages, though there is no fixed formula.
Wage and hour cases carry their own penalty framework that operates independently of the damages described above. Unpaid wages are the starting point, but the penalties stacked on top often dwarf the underlying shortfall. Waiting time penalties (up to 30 days of wages per separated employee). Wage statement penalties ($50 per initial violation, $100 per subsequent violation, up to $4,000 per employee). PAGA civil penalties ($100 per initial violation, $200 per subsequent violation, per employee, per pay period). Liquidated damages (equal to the unpaid wages). Prejudgment interest (7% to 10% per year). These categories multiply across every affected employee and every pay period within the statute of limitations, which is why a relatively modest per-check shortfall can produce a seven-figure case.
Many California employment statutes are fee-shifting, meaning the employer pays the employee’s reasonable attorneys’ fees if the employee prevails. This applies to FEHA claims (discrimination, harassment, retaliation), many Labor Code claims, and PAGA actions. The attorneys’ fees component does not go into your pocket directly, but it means your attorney’s costs are not coming out of your recovery. It also increases the overall pressure on the employer because they know that losing means paying both sides’ legal bills.
Not all cases are equal, and understanding what factors affect case value helps set realistic expectations. Factors that strengthen a case: clear documentation (emails, texts, performance reviews, written complaints). A short and clear timeline between the protected activity and the adverse action. Inconsistent or shifting explanations from the employer. Witnesses who can corroborate your account. A pattern of similar treatment toward other employees. An employer with the financial resources to pay a judgment. Strong comparator evidence showing disparate treatment. Direct evidence of discriminatory or retaliatory intent (statements, emails, texts).
Factors that weaken a case: lack of documentation. A long gap between the protected activity and the adverse action. A legitimate, well-documented performance history that supports the employer’s stated reason. No witnesses or corroborating evidence. An employee who engaged in misconduct that independently justified the adverse action.
At Treger Legal, we evaluate cases honestly. We will not overstate the value of your case to sign you up, and we will not understate the risks to avoid a difficult conversation. If we take your case, it is because we believe in it and because we believe we can deliver a result that justifies the time and effort involved. The consultation is free, and there is no obligation.
This post is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Case values depend on specific facts and circumstances. Consult with a qualified employment attorney.